Sin City: Reviewed

[Ghost [PX]]

I've followed this film closely since I saw the trialer and my jaw hit the floor at how amazing it looked. I've read the first of the three graphic novels that its based off of. I've enjoyed the trialers, the comics and everything to do with this movie. I went into this film with very high expectations and I was most definately not dissappointed. The movie itself was amazing. Just simply jaw dropping. The style, the effects, the mood, the characters, everytyhing was captured perfectly from the novels. The movie itself is more of a translation than an adaptation, simply because the scenes are copied almost perfectly. The actors did an amazing job portraying the characters they played, especially Mickey Roarke who played Marv. The cinematography was probably the best I've seen in any movie in a very long time. The shots were simply jaw dropping in some shots. I have absolutely no beefs with this film at all. There is nothing more they could have done better. The film begins and ends perfectly and the transitions between stories are done very well.

10/10

[Dempsey]

It ruled

http://www.filmrot.com/images/sincity-comparisons/sincity.html

[THE JEW (RaVeN)]

The 1/2 that I saw was pretty good.


I had already read a few, but I downloaded a bunch more of them last night.

[[Fallen]TSB]

i give it like a 6 it was good.. but not that good..

[Paragon]

Sin City ruled. Black and white makes you pay attention to things you never notice otherwise.

[[PX]Kal Bob]

Ok, i finally got to see the movie. I loved it, great movie. I loved the narration style.

I only have one thing to say though "Pulp Fiction" !

[THE JEW (RaVeN)]

Uh:

Sin City: A Dame to Kill For #1----------Pub. Date: November 01, 1993



Pulp Fiction---------------------------------Opened on October 14, 1994



Who's copying who here?


Look at the Dark Knight or even Daredevil as examples of how Miller had been doing this dark type of comic for quite some time.

[[PX]Kal Bob]

I don't mean in the plot of the story, I am referring to the way the multiple stories combine and happen simultaneously.

[THE JEW (RaVeN)]

Watch Stanley Kubrick's "The Killing" for an earlier movie with that type of film progression.


Since you'll have to rent it you can even fast forward through the parts you find boring ala "2001."

[Queen Zeus]

I really did not know what to expect so I went knowing that if was a different kind of film. (From Talking to Paul) I was one of the best films I have seen this year.

9/10

Only because I haven't read the comic so I don't really know how it is suppost to be like.

I loved the narritive style. I hope that they make another one if possible.

[THE JEW (RaVeN)]

When I get time, the Mexican versions of the comics can be distributed.


EDIT:

There's already talk of doing the other full length stories and maybe some of the shorter ones.